Skip to content
Licensed & Insured. CSLB #1092889 Serving the San Fernando Valley & the Westside Service Areas FAQ Client Support (818) 934-0075
MAMOS Construction & Design

Mamos Construction & Design

Tile vs Shingle Roofs in the San Fernando Valley: How Each One Ages and Fails

Get a free roof inspection. Leave your number and we will call you back.

Call (818) 934-0075.

In the Valley you see both tile and shingle roofs. They age and fail in different ways, and each needs different upkeep.

Tile: heavy, durable, and easy to crack

  • What it does well: tile handles sun and heat well and can last a long time when the underlayment beneath it is sound.
  • Where it fails: the tile itself often outlasts the waterproof layer under it. Cracked, slipped or missing pieces let water in, and a person walking on the roof can break more tile.
  • What to watch: broken pieces, slipped rows, loose ridge tiles, and stains on the ceiling below after rain.

Shingle: lighter, simpler, and more sensitive to heat

  • What it does well: shingles are lighter on the structure and usually simpler to repair in sections.
  • Where it fails: long hot summers dry out the surface. You see curling, cracking and loose granules in the gutters.
  • What to watch: bare patches, curled edges, lifted tabs, and granules piling at the downspouts.

Flashing and underlayment

On both roofs, flashing around chimneys, vents and valleys, and the underlayment beneath the surface do much of the real waterproofing. A roof can look fine from the street and still leak at a flashing detail. That is one reason a close look from on the roof beats a photo.

Re-roofing a tile roof is a different job

On a tile roof the tile is usually not what wears out first. The underlayment under it does. So a tile re-roof often means lifting the tiles, replacing the underlayment and flashing, and setting sound tiles back, with new pieces where old ones are broken. A shingle re-roof is simpler: the old layers come off, the deck is checked, and new underlayment, flashing and shingles go on.

Clay barrel tile roof with a new gutter line along the eave
Clay barrel tile with a new gutter line along the eave.

Weight, and switching from one to the other

Tile is much heavier than shingle. Going from shingle to tile can mean checking whether the roof framing can carry the load before anything is ordered. Going from tile to shingle takes weight off, but changes the look of the house, which matters in neighborhoods with design rules or an HOA. Either way, check it at the inspection, before you pick a material.

What a shingle roof shows when it is near the end

On a Los Angeles shingle roof we inspected in September 2026, more than 21 years old, the shingles had lost their granules down to the mat, curled at the edges and cracked at the hips. Valleys were patched with mastic and had no metal flashing. When a shingle roof shows these signs, it is time to replace it.

Lifted and cracked shingles at a hip on an aging Los Angeles roof
Lifted and cracked shingles at a hip on a 21+ year old roof.
Encino roof: new charcoal shingles on, two skylights and vents flashed
Architectural shingles going on during a re-roof we did in Encino.

Choosing tile or shingle

  • If your tile is in good condition, repair usually makes more sense than replacement. A careful inspection tells you whether the underlayment is the real issue.
  • If you have shingles near the end of their life, replacement is straightforward and the options are wide.
  • If your insurer has written to you, a written report on the current condition helps either way.

We inspect Valley roofs regularly, including in Encino, Woodland Hills and Sherman Oaks. The inspection is free and comes as a written report with photos.

Book a free roof inspection

Use the short form at the top of this page or call (818) 934-0075. More: Roofing.

Related reading

☎ Call Schedule a Consultation